Generic manufacturers Hikma and Zentiva are still unable to sell their imitation pemetrexed products in Germany. The Higher Regional Court in Munich passed down a judgment to this effect at the end of February. In Germany, the years-long pemetrexed dispute is now nearing an end.
22 March 2021 by Mathieu Klos
The German pemetrexed dispute is drawing to a close. The Higher Regional Court of Munich has dismissed an appeal by generic manufacturers Hikma and Zentiva against a preliminary injunction handed down the Regional Court of Munich (case ID: 6 U 5222/20 and 6 U 4817/20).
In July 2020, the Munich court ruled in the first instance that Hikma, Zentiva and Stada infringed Eli Lilly patent EP 13 13 508 with their generic pemetrexed products. Thus, the companies could no longer sell the products in Germany (case ID: 21 O 8568/20, 21 O 8569/20 and 21 O 8570/20). In this case, Stada accepted the ruling. However, Hikma and Zentiva both appealed.
But the Higher Regional Court has now confirmed an equivalent infringement of EP 508 by Hikma and Zentiva. Both companies had stopped selling their drugs after the first-instance injunction. The court has ruled the companies cannot put their drugs back on the market until summer.
In June 2021, the market for generic pemetrexed products will open again. However, this coincides with the EP 508 expiry date.
Over the past four years, Eli Lilly and numerous generic manufacturers argued over a combination drug. The previous German pemetrexed dispute centred around the original first patent for pemetrexed.
The parties battled over the infringement and validity of EP 508, which protects the use of the disodium salt of pemetrexed in combination with vitamin B12. Eli Lilly’s drug is marketed under the brand name Alimta, and is used in palliative chemotherapy for certain advanced forms of lung cancer.
At the beginning of July 2020, the Federal Court of Justice ruled that EP 508 is valid (case ID: X ZR 150/18). With this decision, the court overturned the decision of the Federal Patent Court. In doing so, the court turned the tide for generic companies that had introduced their products in Germany after the lower court’s nullity verdict in 2018.
For almost two years, the generic companies sold their pemetrexed products. Then, immediately after the Federal Court decision, US originator Eli Lilly filed for preliminary injunctions against Hikma, Stada and Zentiva.
The defendants’ imitation products use active ingredient pemetrexed diarginine. The generics producers argue that this formulation does not infringe the original patent of Eli Lilly, which protects the form with disodium salt of pemetrexed.
However, the generic products have now failed in both court because of equivalent patent infringement.
Even the Higher Regional Court’s verdict is unlikely to be the end of the dispute over the cancer drug. Various generic drug manufacturers have been on the market with their imitation products between 2018 and 2020. So, the question of compensation remains.
The question now is whether Hikma and Zentiva will agree to compensate Eli Lilly. If they do not, Eli Lilly is likely to file lawsuits on the merits to have the compensation determined by the court. Such lawsuits typically drag on for many years.
Neither Eli Lilly nor the generics manufacturers have decided on the next steps, according to information from JUVE Patent.
Eli Lilly and various generic companies are also battling over pemetrexed in Belgium, France, Italy, Spain, Scandinavia and the Netherlands.
All advisors maintain long-standing contacts with clients. In almost all cases, the advisors have accompanied the clients since proceedings began.
Eli Lilly has very strong ties to international law firm Hogan Lovells, and patent attorney boutique König Szynka Tilmann von Renesse in Germany. A mixed team from both firms already achieved the landmark win over Olanzapin for the originator in 2008.
The London office of Hogan Lovells co-ordinates all European proceedings for the pemetrexed patent, through partner Daniel Brook.
In the appeal before the Higher Regional Court in Munich, Hikma also relied on patent firms Preu Bohlig & Partner and Hamm & Wittkopp. Hikma began the dispute with the firms from the beginning, while Zentiva has also worked with Arnold Ruess and Hoffmann Eitle since proceedings began.
In this – presumably last – round of the German pemetrexed dispute Hexal and Stada were not involved. Previously, Hexal relied on a team of lawyers from Taylor Wessing and patent attorneys from Lederer & Keller.
However, the company did not feature in the series of preliminary injunctions.
Bird & Bird acted for several generic companies in the dispute over pemetrexed. A mixed team led by patent attorney Michael Alt and litigator Anna Wolters-Höhne supported Fresenius in the nullity proceedings.
At the same time, Düsseldorf partner and litigator Oliver Jüngst advised Stada, working together with patent attorney Thomas Kernebeck and Hamburg patent attorney firm Hamm & Wittkopp.
Furthermore, name partner Alexander Wittkopp also advised Hikma Pharmaceuticals together with Preu Bohlig partner Daniel Hoppe.
For Eli Lilly
Hogan Lovells (Düsseldorf): Andreas von Falck, Stephan Neuhaus; associates: Martin Koch, Lukas Sievers, Maximiliane Häußling
König Szynka Tilmann von Renesse (Düsseldorf): Gregor König, Claudia Hertzsch (both patent attorneys)
In-house (London): Ivan Burnside
In-house (Bad Homburg): Nicole Könecke
For Hikma Pharmaceuticals
Preu Bohlig & Partner (Hamburg): Daniel Hoppe; Alice Pasch, Christian Holtz
Hamm & Wittkopp (Hamburg): Alexander Wittkopp (patent attorney)
For Zentiva Pharma
Arnold Ruess (Düsseldorf): Cordula Schumacher, Theresa Schulz
Hoffmann Eitle (Munich): Martin Bachelin (patent attorney)
In-house (Prague) Kirstin Cooklin (Head of Intellectual Property)
Higher Regional Court Munich, 6th Senate
Konrad Retzer (presiding judge)
Eli Lilly has achieved a ban on the sale of imitation pemetrexed products in Germany, in the ongoing dispute over its cancer drug ...28 July 2020 by Konstanze Richter
The Paris Court of First Instance has once again granted Eli Lilly a preliminary injunction for pemetrexed. The judges also grant ...28 January 2021 by Christina Schulze
A French court has banned Fresenius from selling a competing pemetrexed product in France, in the pan-European dispute over Eli L ...15 September 2020 by Christina Schulze
A long-standing dispute over cancer drug Alimta, which contains the active ingredient pemetrexed, has taken a new turn. The paten ...16 August 2019 by Konstanze Richter
In a lasting dispute over the cancer drug Alimta, several generic drug manufacturers have achieved a significant win against Eli ...4 April 2019 by Konstanze Richter
Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper function of the website.
|Provider||Owner of this website|
|Purpose||Saves the visitors preferences selected in the Cookie Box of Borlabs Cookie.|
|Cookie Expiry||1 Year|
|Purpose||Cookie by Google used to control advanced script and event handling.|
|Cookie Expiry||1 Year|
Statistics cookies collect information anonymously. This information helps us to understand how our visitors use our website.
|Purpose||Cookie by Google used for website analytics. Generates statistical data on how the visitor uses the website.|
|Cookie Expiry||1 Year|
Marketing cookies are used by third-party advertisers or publishers to display personalized ads. They do this by tracking visitors across websites.
|Purpose||Hotjar is an user behavior analytic tool by Hotjar Ltd.. We use Hotjar to understand how users interact with our website.|
|Cookie Name||_hjClosedSurveyInvites, _hjDonePolls, _hjMinimizedPolls, _hjDoneTestersWidgets, _hjIncludedInSample, _hjShownFeedbackMessage, _hjid, _hjRecordingLastActivity, hjTLDTest, _hjUserAttributesHash, _hjCachedUserAttributes, _hjLocalStorageTest, _hjptid|
|Cookie Expiry||Session / 1 Year|
Content from video platforms and social media platforms is blocked by default. If External Media cookies are accepted, access to those contents no longer requires manual consent.
|Purpose||Used to unblock Facebook content.|
|Purpose||Used to unblock Google Maps content.|
|Cookie Expiry||6 Month|
|Purpose||Used to unblock Instagram content.|
|Purpose||Used to unblock OpenStreetMap content.|
|Cookie Name||_osm_location, _osm_session, _osm_totp_token, _osm_welcome, _pk_id., _pk_ref., _pk_ses., qos_token|
|Cookie Expiry||1-10 Years|
|Purpose||Used to unblock Twitter content.|
|Cookie Name||__widgetsettings, local_storage_support_test|
|Purpose||Used to unblock Vimeo content.|
|Cookie Expiry||2 Years|
|Purpose||Used to unblock YouTube content.|
|Cookie Expiry||6 Month|