The UK High Court has found a patent held by PanOptis and owned by its subsidiary Unwired Planet as valid and infringed by Apple. But no injunction has been ordered against the US tech company, as Apple is to take a court-determined licence. The technical trial is one of many in an ongoing series of proceedings over 3G and 4G technology standards.
20 October 2020 by Amy Sandys
The UK High Court has declared an Unwired Planet patent, which is held by parent company PanOptis, valid and infringed by Apple (case ID: HP – 2019 -000006). The court also rejected Apple’s counterclaim for revocation. Presiding judge Colin Birss only heard the case on 13 October, handing down a provisional judgment on 16 October. However, Apple has avoided an injunction, with the court declaring the party will accept a ‘court-determined licence’ in agreement between the two parties. The patent expires today.
Interestingly, EP 12 30 818 was filed on 20 October 2000, claiming priority from a US filing dated 17 November 1999. With a patent expiry time of 20 years, the patent therefore expires today – 20 October 2020. This is just seven days after the end date of the trial. The Optis Cellular Technology group holds a portfolio of standard essential patents, of which EP 818 is a part. The group accuses Apple of infringing seven patents altogether.
EP 818 relates to a method improving the handover between mobile communication systems. The UK High Court found EP 818 valid and infringed by Apple, although the tech company argued that the patent was not essential. Apple also claimed the patent invalid on the grounds of obviousness and insufficiency. However, the court rejected both arguments.
Arty Rajendra
The case between PanOptis and Apple concerns several technical trials, the first of which took place in October 2020. The court has scheduled the next technical trial for spring 2021.
In July 2021, the FRAND trial begins; it is the first time a UK court has split the FRAND issues into two trials.
The first trial will consider whether the implementer is an ‘unwilling licensee’. The second trial will focus on global licencing and competition law.
Both are currently novel points of law in England, given the UK Supreme Court’s recent decisions in Unwired Planet vs. Huawei, and Conversant vs. Huawei and ZTE. Currently, PanOptis and Apple are also engaged in parallel US proceedings.
Once again, PanOptis ran the case with an EIP team lead by Gary Moss. Previously, the firm was also active for PanOptis subsidiary Unwired Planet in the FRAND landmark case before the UK Supreme Court. Co-counsel for PanOptis, as well as for Unwired Planet, is Osborne Clarke partner Arty Rajendra.
Barristers Adrian Speck and Thomas Jones of 8 New Square have already led the proceedings for Unwired Planet.
Gary Moss
On the other hand, Apple relies on Guy Burkhill and Brian Nicholson from 3 New Square. WilmerHale partner Justin Watts, who is Apple’s first choice for UK proceedings, instructed the barrister set, alongside partner Anthony Trenton.
For PanOptis
8 New Square (London): Adrian Speck, Mark Chacksfield, Thomas Jones
EIP (London): Gary Moss, Robert Lundie Smith, Jerome Spaargaren, David Brinck (partners); associates: Jo Welch, Jack Dickerson, Sunny Bansal; paralegal: Steph Harris
Osborne Clarke (London): Arty Rajendra (partner); associate: Lucy Paull (competition law)
For Apple
3 New Square (London): Guy Burkhill, Brian Nicholson
Blackstone Chambers (London): Michael Bloch
WilmerHale (London): Justin Watts, Anthony Trenton (both partners)
UK High Court of Justice, London
Colin Birss (presiding judge)
The UK courts have jurisdiction to grant a global FRAND licence and injunctions based on a UK patent. This is the outcome of the ...
26 August 2020 by Mathieu KlosPanoptis, the parent company of Unwired Planet, and Huawei have reached a settlement which ends their litigation in the US and Ge ...
27 April 2020 by Mathieu KlosA claim by Huawei and ZTE, that Chinese, rather than English courts should hear claims by non-practicing entity Conversant, has b ...
4 February 2019 by Amy SandysThe UK judiciary has announced the promotion of Colin Birss to the UK Court of Appeal. Birss, a specialist IP judge, joins the Co ...
17 August 2020 by Amy SandysWe use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential, while others help us to improve this website and your experience.
Here you will find an overview of all cookies used. You can give your consent to whole categories or display further information and select certain cookies.
Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper function of the website.
Name | |
---|---|
Provider | Owner of this website |
Purpose | Saves the visitors preferences selected in the Cookie Box of Borlabs Cookie. |
Cookie Name | borlabs-cookie |
Cookie Expiry | 1 Year |
Name | |
---|---|
Provider | Google LLC |
Purpose | Cookie by Google used to control advanced script and event handling. |
Privacy Policy | https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en |
Cookie Name | _ga,_gat,_gid |
Cookie Expiry | 1 Year |
Statistics cookies collect information anonymously. This information helps us to understand how our visitors use our website.
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | Google LLC |
Purpose | Cookie by Google used for website analytics. Generates statistical data on how the visitor uses the website. |
Privacy Policy | https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en |
Cookie Name | _ga,_gat,_gid |
Cookie Expiry | 1 Year |
Marketing cookies are used by third-party advertisers or publishers to display personalized ads. They do this by tracking visitors across websites.
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | Hotjar Ltd. |
Purpose | Hotjar is an user behavior analytic tool by Hotjar Ltd.. We use Hotjar to understand how users interact with our website. |
Privacy Policy | https://www.hotjar.com/legal/policies/privacy/ |
Host(s) | *.hotjar.com |
Cookie Name | _hjClosedSurveyInvites, _hjDonePolls, _hjMinimizedPolls, _hjDoneTestersWidgets, _hjIncludedInSample, _hjShownFeedbackMessage, _hjid, _hjRecordingLastActivity, hjTLDTest, _hjUserAttributesHash, _hjCachedUserAttributes, _hjLocalStorageTest, _hjptid |
Cookie Expiry | Session / 1 Year |
Content from video platforms and social media platforms is blocked by default. If External Media cookies are accepted, access to those contents no longer requires manual consent.
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | |
Purpose | Used to unblock Facebook content. |
Privacy Policy | https://www.facebook.com/privacy/explanation |
Host(s) | .facebook.com |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | |
Purpose | Used to unblock Google Maps content. |
Privacy Policy | https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en&gl=en |
Host(s) | .google.com |
Cookie Name | NID |
Cookie Expiry | 6 Month |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | |
Purpose | Used to unblock Instagram content. |
Privacy Policy | https://www.instagram.com/legal/privacy/ |
Host(s) | .instagram.com |
Cookie Name | pigeon_state |
Cookie Expiry | Session |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | OpenStreetMap Foundation |
Purpose | Used to unblock OpenStreetMap content. |
Privacy Policy | https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/wiki/Privacy_Policy |
Host(s) | .openstreetmap.org |
Cookie Name | _osm_location, _osm_session, _osm_totp_token, _osm_welcome, _pk_id., _pk_ref., _pk_ses., qos_token |
Cookie Expiry | 1-10 Years |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | |
Purpose | Used to unblock Twitter content. |
Privacy Policy | https://twitter.com/privacy |
Host(s) | .twimg.com, .twitter.com |
Cookie Name | __widgetsettings, local_storage_support_test |
Cookie Expiry | Unlimited |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | Vimeo |
Purpose | Used to unblock Vimeo content. |
Privacy Policy | https://vimeo.com/privacy |
Host(s) | player.vimeo.com |
Cookie Name | vuid |
Cookie Expiry | 2 Years |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | YouTube |
Purpose | Used to unblock YouTube content. |
Privacy Policy | https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en&gl=en |
Host(s) | google.com |
Cookie Name | NID |
Cookie Expiry | 6 Month |