Divisional applications and double patenting is an issue in Europe. According to experts it is particularly common in the life sciences industry. At this year's World Congress in Hamburg, the AIPPI addressed the issue. Koen Bijvank, partner at Brinkhof, spearheaded the adoption of a related resolution and outlined the key demands to JUVE Patent.
17 November 2026 by Mathieu Klos
What legal uncertainties currently exist regarding divisional patent applications and double patenting – particularly in Europe?
Koen Bijvank: “It is not allowed to obtain two patents that protect exactly the same. When these patents have different filing dates, the novelty requirements ensures that the later patent must be different in order to be valid. Since a divisional patent has the same filing date as its parent, the novelty requirement cannot prevent double patenting for divisionals. The resolution takes a position on how the undesirability of double patenting affects the filing and validity of divisional patent applications.”
In brief, what did the AIPPI decide in the resolution?
“AIPPI has taken the position that double patenting is undesirable. In case of double patenting, this must be resolvable by amending or abandoning one of the patent (applications). The resolution also affirms AIPPI’s position on the opportunities that an applicant must have to file divisional applications.”
AIPPI had already adopted a resolution on this topic back in 2007. What are the key changes introduced by the Hamburg resolution?
“Resolution Q193 mainly addresses the procedural possibilities of filing divisional applications. The new resolution Q297 focusses on double patenting issues related to divisional applications.”
AIPPI received 44 submissions from national groups and independent members. Were the positions widely divergent?
“There were certainly points where the positions of the national groups diverged, for instance on whether protection for the same subject matter by different types of rights should be permitted or not.”
You are qualified as a patent attorney and lawyer and are also active at the UPC. What practical problems do you encounter related to this issue in your advisory practice?
“It sometimes happens that a patent looks likely to be revoked while there are still one or more divisional applications pending. This allows patent owners to adjust the claims of these divisional applications to improve their chances of surviving an invalidity attack. But also creates uncertainty for third parties because, despite the original patent no longer being enforceable, there may be further patents protecting more or less the same invention.”
Is this a global issue?
“I do not have a complete overview of the situation in the individual jurisdictions. But I can say that it is an issue in Europe. We come across it mainly in the life sciences sector. In principle, it can also occur when patenting in other sectors, but we are currently not observing it in other fields.”
“There are ways under procedural law and/or competition law in most jurisdictions to address abusive behaviour.”
Point 11 of the resolution particularly catches my eye; in my own words, it states: ‘No restriction on the right to file divisional applications in order to prevent abusive market behaviour by patent holders.’ This is where the ‘divisional game’ – currently the subject of heated debate – comes into play. Do AIPPI members have any ideas on how abusive market behaviour by patent holders might instead be prevented?
“There are ways under procedural law and/or competition law in most jurisdictions to address abusive behaviour.”
What is AIPPI now doing to ensure that the contents of the resolution are incorporated into national law or the European Patent Convention?
“The national groups are now encouraged to provide the text of all AIPPI’s resolutions to lawmakers and governmental institutions concerned with the protection of intellectual property. AIPPI also uses the resolutions as a basis for contributions in Standing Committees at WIPO, where AIPPI has observer status, and in meetings of the B+ group of countries. It also forms the basis for position papers and submissions in response to consultations from intellectual property offices around world.”
Which patent-related topics will the participants discuss at the next World Congress in Cannes?
“Cross-border enforcement will be a major topic in Cannes.”
The interview was conducted by Mathieu Klos.
You are currently viewing a placeholder content from Facebook. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
More InformationYou are currently viewing a placeholder content from Instagram. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
More InformationYou are currently viewing a placeholder content from X. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
More Information