US medical device manufacturer Boston Scientific has successfully defended a patent for heart valves before the European Patent Office. The Boards of Appeal upheld patent EP 2 749 254 to a limited extent.
27 February 2019 by Konstanze Richter
In May 2017, an anonymous opponent represented by the Munich patent law firm Lang & Tomerius withdrew its opposition to the Boston Scientific patent for unknown reasons. Another opponent, US manufacturer Edwards Lifesciences, withdrew its opposition claim after reaching a settlement with Boston Scientific in January 2019.
Of the original three opponents to file opposition suits against Boston Scientific, Irish medical device manufacturer Medtronic was the only remaining opponent in proceedings against Boston Scientific at the EPO.
Boston Scientific and Edwards Lifesciences had previously been locked in a fierce dispute over the EP 254 patent now upheld by the EPO. At the end of October 2015, Boston Scientific filed an infringement suit against Edwards Lifesciences at Düsseldorf Regional Court.
Anne Schön
After the Court of First Instance ruled in favour of the plaintiff and confirmed an infringement, the defendant appealed to the Higher Regional Court Düsseldorf. Edwards Lifesciences also filed an entitlement action at the Regional Court Munich. As a result, the Higher Regional Court Düsseldorf initially suspended the appeal proceedings on the question of infringement. However, in the suspension order the judge confirmed the decision of the first instance.
At the same time, opposition proceedings against the patent were being conducted at the EPO. In late 2017, the EPO published its decision to maintain the patent in a limited form. Edwards Lifesciences appealed against this.
Like all other infringement and opposition proceedings this dispute then ended with the global settlement between Boston Scientific and Edwards Lifesciences.
While Edwards Lifesciences and the remaining opponent Medtronic have also clashed in court in the past, there have been no previous legal disputes between Medtronic and Boston Scientific.
Boston Scientific retained its long-standing advisor for the opposition proceedings, Peterreins Schley, which had previously assisted the US company in various infringement suits.
Frank Peterreins
Partner Peterreins, who is qualified as both attorney-at-law and patent attorney, advised the client during his time at Fish & Richardson.
Medtronic also instructed its regular counsel. Mixed law firm Hoffmann Eitle has been managing a partial portfolio for the medical technology company for years.
In addition to the prosecution work conducted by its patent attorneys, the firm’s litigators also regularly advise the company on infringement proceedings, such as the suit against Edwards Lifesciences in 2014.
For Boston Scientific
Peterreins Schley (Munich): Frank Peterreins; patent attorneys: Jan-Malte Schley, Matthias Traut
For Medtronic
Hoffmann Eitle: Mark Jones (Munich): Anne Schön, Jeremias Wollschlaeger (both patent attorneys)
EPO Boards of Appeal, Munich Haar
We use cookies on our website. Some of them are essential, while others help us to improve this website and your experience.
Here you will find an overview of all cookies used. You can give your consent to whole categories or display further information and select certain cookies.
Essential cookies enable basic functions and are necessary for the proper function of the website.
Name | |
---|---|
Provider | Owner of this website |
Purpose | Saves the visitors preferences selected in the Cookie Box of Borlabs Cookie. |
Cookie Name | borlabs-cookie |
Cookie Expiry | 1 Year |
Name | |
---|---|
Provider | Google LLC |
Purpose | Cookie by Google used to control advanced script and event handling. |
Privacy Policy | https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en |
Cookie Name | _ga,_gat,_gid |
Cookie Expiry | 1 Year |
Statistics cookies collect information anonymously. This information helps us to understand how our visitors use our website.
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | Google LLC |
Purpose | Cookie by Google used for website analytics. Generates statistical data on how the visitor uses the website. |
Privacy Policy | https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en |
Cookie Name | _ga,_gat,_gid |
Cookie Expiry | 1 Year |
Marketing cookies are used by third-party advertisers or publishers to display personalized ads. They do this by tracking visitors across websites.
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | Hotjar Ltd. |
Purpose | Hotjar is an user behavior analytic tool by Hotjar Ltd.. We use Hotjar to understand how users interact with our website. |
Privacy Policy | https://www.hotjar.com/legal/policies/privacy/ |
Host(s) | *.hotjar.com |
Cookie Name | _hjClosedSurveyInvites, _hjDonePolls, _hjMinimizedPolls, _hjDoneTestersWidgets, _hjIncludedInSample, _hjShownFeedbackMessage, _hjid, _hjRecordingLastActivity, hjTLDTest, _hjUserAttributesHash, _hjCachedUserAttributes, _hjLocalStorageTest, _hjptid |
Cookie Expiry | Session / 1 Year |
Content from video platforms and social media platforms is blocked by default. If External Media cookies are accepted, access to those contents no longer requires manual consent.
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | |
Purpose | Used to unblock Facebook content. |
Privacy Policy | https://www.facebook.com/privacy/explanation |
Host(s) | .facebook.com |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | |
Purpose | Used to unblock Google Maps content. |
Privacy Policy | https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en&gl=en |
Host(s) | .google.com |
Cookie Name | NID |
Cookie Expiry | 6 Month |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | |
Purpose | Used to unblock Instagram content. |
Privacy Policy | https://www.instagram.com/legal/privacy/ |
Host(s) | .instagram.com |
Cookie Name | pigeon_state |
Cookie Expiry | Session |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | OpenStreetMap Foundation |
Purpose | Used to unblock OpenStreetMap content. |
Privacy Policy | https://wiki.osmfoundation.org/wiki/Privacy_Policy |
Host(s) | .openstreetmap.org |
Cookie Name | _osm_location, _osm_session, _osm_totp_token, _osm_welcome, _pk_id., _pk_ref., _pk_ses., qos_token |
Cookie Expiry | 1-10 Years |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | |
Purpose | Used to unblock Twitter content. |
Privacy Policy | https://twitter.com/privacy |
Host(s) | .twimg.com, .twitter.com |
Cookie Name | __widgetsettings, local_storage_support_test |
Cookie Expiry | Unlimited |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | Vimeo |
Purpose | Used to unblock Vimeo content. |
Privacy Policy | https://vimeo.com/privacy |
Host(s) | player.vimeo.com |
Cookie Name | vuid |
Cookie Expiry | 2 Years |
Accept | |
---|---|
Name | |
Provider | YouTube |
Purpose | Used to unblock YouTube content. |
Privacy Policy | https://policies.google.com/privacy?hl=en&gl=en |
Host(s) | google.com |
Cookie Name | NID |
Cookie Expiry | 6 Month |